WARNING
As you might notice after reading my recommendations (at the bottom) I tend to prefer shows aimed at women. I will probably often review shows dealing with romance and drama rather than battles, much of them will be shoujo and I am a big fan of BL (boy love) stories. I've had people hassle me before, and I'd like to avoid that by stating it here; you are warned of what I like, please don't harass me over it.
My Favorites - Recommendations
These are my favorite manga and anime of all time, and are the ones I tend to suggest to people first. You may notice a similar theme, but I do tend to watch a wide variety of things, this is just my preferred taste. In no particular order than how it came out of my head....
Kaze to Ki no Uta
Kimi wa Petto
YuGiOh! (Give the manga a chance, seriously)
Loveless
Fruits Basket
Hourou Musuko
Girl Friends
07-Ghost
Kuroshitsuji
Gundam Wing
Angel Beats
Digimon Tamers
Spiral: Suiri no Kizuna
......and pretty much anything by CLAMP
